Wednesday, October 7, 2026

THE HARMONICA - EVOLUTION FROM THE SHENG

from SHENG to HARMONICA ...

Today we get to take a look at where the harmonica came from. In order to do that, we must look into a little bit of historical evidence. In the Smithsonian Magazine, Steve Knopper writes, "Many harmonica histories begin around 1100 B.C. with the sheng, a Chinese instrument featuring a bundle of bamboo tubes attached to a curving pipe. This instrument contains a free reed ..." (Knopper). Like me, you may ask, what is a free reed? National Music Museum states, "Free reeds are aerophones in which the sound is produced by air set into motion by a thin strip of material (reed) set into a slotted frame. The air can be supplied by the player's breath, bellows, or other air pump devices" (National Music Museum). Knopper's article suggests that the harmonica does not directly come from the sheng. It may be even more representative of the "talking machine" that was invented by a Dutchman, Christian Gottlieb Kratzenstein. This machine also utilized the free reed and was much very large (Knopper). Knopper states, "... more musically minded inventors reduced the size of Kratzenstein's device, calling their various creations a terpodian or harmonium. The pocket-size "mouth organ" arrived in the 1820s and would spread throughout Europe, and then the United States" (Knopper). This is a short history of how the Chinese sheng evolved into the harmonica. 

listen to the SHENG 

Below is an example of what the sheng sounds like when played.


listen to the HARMONICA

The video below shows what a harmonica sounds like. This is Buddy Greene performing on the harmonica.


analysis

Here we will discuss how the sheng and harmonica are similar and also how they are different as the harmonica descended from the sheng. Both the harmonica and sheng can play different tempos and dynamics. In addition, the length of the produced sound is regulated by the breath put into the instrument. In contrast, there are musical elements that are different between the sheng and the harmonica. 
    
The timbre of the sheng is somewhat hollow. The timbre is also clearer than that of a harmonica. In addition, it almost sounds as if there is more than one instrument playing because of the number of notes that can be layered and staggered being played by the sheng. 
   
In contrast, the harmonica has a thicker and cloudier timbre. Though multiple notes can be played at once they always move in the same direction, all together. Because of the way that notes are played on this instrument even though there are multiple notes being played at the same time, it never sounds like there is more than one instrument playing.

my response 

Both of these instruments are amazing. The sheng was a new introduction for me while my brother can play the harmonica, so I have heard it played in my family. I really like both of these instruments. The layers of notes that the sheng can play is neat to listen to. If I could not see that it was one single instrument playing, I would guess that there were a few different instruments that were playing. It communicates a more anxious and tense feeling (in the second part of the example movie) to me than the harmonica. I like the thick full timbre of the harmonica and even when the notes are being played quickly, they are all going in one direction making it easier and more enjoyable for my brain to listen to the music. In my opinion, I would rather listen to the harmonica; however, the sheng is special in its own way. We must also keep in mind that without the sheng, we would not have the harmonica. 

works cited

Knopper, S. "A Brief History of the Harmonica." Smithsonian magazine, Apr. 2021, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/history-harmonica-180977157/. Accessed 6 Oct. 2026.

National Music Museum. "Free Reeds." National music museum, eMuseum, 2026, https://emuseum.nmmusd.org/groups/free-reeds. Accessed 6 Oct. 2026.





1 comment:

  1. Wow! I have never heard of the sheng before, that is very interesting. I have to agree that I like the harmonica more. I have always preferred a fuller, deeper timbre to an instrument and the sheng sounds a little bit shrill to me. I never would have thought that the harmonica could have come from an instrument like the sheng, especially when you consider the genres we most often hear the harmonica in, like blues and folk music.

    ReplyDelete

MUSIC AND THE FICTIVE DREAM - THE SOUND OF MUSIC

  About The   Sound of Music In 1965, The Sound of Music, "a ... musical drama film produced and directed by Robert Wise," was rel...